Asana or ClickUp? Which tool to choose to manage my projects in 2023

Table of contents

Disclaimer: UpSys Consulting specializes in the implementation of ClickUp. We have established expertise and processes for this tool. However, we are committed to offering the most unbiased comparison in this article, based on an analysis of these solutions and our project management experience with numerous clients.

In this comprehensive guide, we'll dissect and compare two top-tier project management tools - ClickUp and Asana.

ClickUp vs Asana : Interface

Interface Asana
An in-depth look at Asana's interface

Asana boasts a side navigation bar featuring six sections: Home, My Tasks, Inbox, Reports, Portfolios, and Goals. There's also a Team section that centralizes and groups tasks.

Within a team, we can create projects. Once inside a project, several views are available, such as the overview and timeline views. Clicking on a task opens it in a side panel. Asana's interface is user-friendly and simple to navigate.

Similarly, ClickUp offers various features through its left navigation bar, including: Home, Notifications, Goals, Favorites, Spaces (the equivalent of Teams in Asana), Folders (akin to Projects in Asana), and Lists. It's evident that ClickUp offers an additional level of task structure sophistication with its Lists feature.

Distinct features between these two tools become apparent when exploring Dashboards (which Asana lacks) and Documents. ClickUp also provides more view options than Asana.

When we click on a task, it displays in a pop-up, instead of directing us to a different page:

Just like Asana, additional options appear at the top of the screen (the number of features depends on the package used).

At this stage of comparison, ClickUp and Asana appear very similar. However, a deeper dive into these tools and their features will reveal their distinctiveness.

Both tools have a section that provides an overview of our daily work. In Asana, this section is called "My Tasks," while in ClickUp, it's called "My Work."

A key difference here is that Asana displays a small task list, whereas ClickUp presents a broader goal.

Interface de ClickUp
L'interface de Clickup en quelques images

In ClickUp, we see a calendar or schedule on the right side of the Home screen. Asana lacks this feature, instead, we see our recent projects on the right side of the Home screen. ClickUp's equivalent to this would be the Trending section, found at the top of the Home page.

Conclusion: Both tools ultimately offer similar interfaces, and the choice comes down to personal preference. ClickUp's extensive functionality may initially make it more complex to approach, but it remains as intuitive as Asana once you get the hang of it.

ClickUp vs Asana: Available Templates

A pivotal aspect of project management platforms is their capacity to offer ready-made templates. These templates can considerably streamline your work process by providing a predefined structure to align your tasks and objectives.

Asana Templates

One of the distinct advantages of Asana over ClickUp is the clarity of purpose in their templates. They're presented in a way that makes it easy to understand their layout and potential applications. Each project template is thoughtfully designed with its specific use-case in mind.

Asana's dynamic and comprehensive range of templates, like Interfunctional Projects, Work Requests, One-on-One Meetings, Business Plans, Bug Tracking, and more, cater to a variety of project needs. So, whether you're launching a marketing campaign or crafting a business strategy, there's a suitable Asana template that's just a few clicks away.

On the other hand, ClickUp also offers an expansive library of templates. However, its approach can seem overwhelming due to the redundancy in its template options, as seen with the five different templates for agile project management.

ClickUp Templates

ClickUp's extensive template selection includes options for different workspaces, folders, and lists, offering a high degree of customization.

Conclusion: In terms of templates, Asana has an edge due to its streamlined, purpose-focused approach. On ClickUp, while the redundancy in templates may cause initial decision-making confusion, it is important to note that the platform's template creation feature is more robust than Asana's. This allows for greater flexibility and customization once you're familiar with the tool's functionalities.

Clickup vs Asana : Fonctionnalités clés

Dans cette section, nous allons nous intéresser aux principales différences entre ces deux outils. La philosophie des deux applications est différente. Là où Asana s'efforce d'être le meilleur outil de gestion des tâches, ClickUp, quant à lui, a pour objectif d'être "l'outil qui les remplace tous".

Par conséquent, ClickUp a tendance à créer de nombreuses fonctionnalités en interne, alors qu'Asana facilite énormément son intégration avec d'autres outils.

ClickUp vs Asana: Key Features

In this section, we're delving into the core differences between these two project management tools. Asana and ClickUp each have a unique philosophy: while Asana strives to excel as a task management tool, ClickUp aims to be the "one-app-to-replace-them-all".

As a result, ClickUp tends to develop a myriad of in-house features, whereas Asana emphasizes easy integrations with other tools.

ClickUp: Key Features

ClickUp Docs

Where ClickUp truly distinguishes itself from Asana is in its dual utility as both a task management tool and a document management system. ClickUp enables you to create, format, and share a knowledge base or documents within your projects.

ClickUp Docs

The ClickUp Docs feature allows you to develop comprehensive knowledge bases, like the displayed training material.

ClickUp Template Creation

While both tools offer templates, ClickUp takes the lead with its more sophisticated models, the ability to create templates at every hierarchy level, and the opportunity to combine them with automations.

ClickUp Views

ClickUp offers more views than Asana: 11 in total versus Asana's six. ClickUp's additional views, which aren't present in Asana, include Gantt, Workload, and Capacity views. These are particularly useful for managing task dependencies and assigning users based on their availability.

Emails from ClickUp

ClickUp allows you to send and receive emails directly within the platform, with the added convenience of incorporating email templates. This feature is especially handy if you're using ClickUp as a CRM tool.

ClickUp's Relationships and Rollups

ClickUp introduces a unique system of relationships that allows you to interlink two or more tasks. This is a powerful feature when building a small network of data for recruitment systems or managing Epics/User Stories.

Whiteboard View

Another noteworthy feature of ClickUp is its whiteboard view. This eliminates the need to purchase a separate whiteboard tool such as FigJam or Miro, saving costs and reducing the number of tools your team has to navigate.

Tableau blanc ClickUp

Conclusion: In terms of feature richness, ClickUp holds a substantial edge with its holistic approach. From document management to inter-task relationships, it provides numerous advanced functionalities that, once mastered, can significantly enhance your project management efficiency.

Asana's Key Features

Asana Overview

An intriguing feature of Asana is its Overview function. It provides users with a snapshot of their daily work progress, keeping them abreast of the ongoing developments in their tasks.

Asana's Security and Visibility

When it comes to security functions, Asana outperforms ClickUp. ClickUp's offerings tend to be more limited, even with its enterprise plan.

Asana's Native Integrations

The critical philosophical difference between ClickUp and Asana lies in Asana's reliance on third-party integrations to deliver a comprehensive solution. If you're looking to link your favorite tools with Asana, it's a breeze! There's no need for additional third-party tools like Make or Zapier to connect them. Asana can seamlessly integrate with a host of tools, including Salesforce, Jira, Tableau, Vimeo, and more.

Asana's Many Integrations

Conclusion: While ClickUp takes the lead with more extensive in-house features, including its ability to serve as a wiki or document management tool, Asana compensates for its fewer features with native integrations with leading market applications. It demonstrates that both tools excel in their distinct ways, and your choice should align with your specific project management needs and workflow preferences.

ClickUp vs Asana: Automations

In Asana, the automation system is known as Rules and Processes. With around 70 rules available, you can automate your workflows in a variety of ways. Asana offers a gallery of predefined rules, allowing you to quickly design automation around assignments, forms, due dates, dependencies, and more.

Notably, Asana goes beyond ClickUp when it comes to integrating automation rules with other applications, such as Slack, Gmail, and Outlook, which enhances its usability and flexibility.

On the other hand, ClickUp also offers a robust automation system. You can utilize existing automation templates or create your own through a straightforward if/then condition system. Its intuitive interface and flexible trigger conditions make automation creation a breeze. However, it falls a bit short when it comes to native integration with other applications.

Conclusion: In essence, both ClickUp and Asana are rich in automation capabilities. However, the final choice depends on your particular needs. If your tasks heavily rely on other apps like Slack, Gmail, or Outlook, you might find Asana's automation features more beneficial. Conversely, if you prefer customizability and simplicity in setting up your automation rules, ClickUp could be your go-to tool. Remember, a tool's effectiveness ultimately depends on how well it aligns with your team's workflow and requirements.

ClickUp vs Asana: Pricing

Both ClickUp and Asana offer a free tier, but a closer look at what's included reveals that ClickUp tends to offer more features in its free plan than Asana. In fact, ClickUp's free tier could be more than enough for a small team or an individual, while with Asana's free plan, you might quickly find yourself feeling constrained.

Furthermore, ClickUp offers five pricing tiers, compared to Asana's three. Notably, ClickUp's Business tier at $12 per year provides features equivalent to those in Asana's tier priced at €24.99 per month.

Given the range of features that ClickUp offers on its free plan, many users might find that they can manage quite comfortably using ClickUp for free. In Asana, you'll need at least the Premium plan to start accessing comparable features.

Conclusion: ClickUp offers a more budget-friendly option, delivering as many features as Asana, if not more, for a lower cost. To sign up for ClickUp, click here.

ClickUp vs Asana: Conclusions

Asana is the best software for you if...

If you don't want to spend much time learning how to set up software and prefer to dive right into work, Asana might be the tool for you. It offers fewer features, but it's more stable and has been developed for a longer period of time.

Choose Asana if:

  • You're a novice when it comes to project management apps.
  • You prefer a traditional project management tool.
  • You favor simplicity and are overwhelmed by highly comprehensive apps.
  • You are a small team or don't mind paying for more than 15 users.

ClickUp is the best software for you if...

If you're seeking additional features, relatively low cost, and more possibilities for configuration and functionality, ClickUp could be the tool for you.

Choose ClickUp if:

  • You're operating on a tight budget.
  • You're interested in a more robust collaboration app beyond just project management.
  • You value advanced customization and are prepared to learn.

Why UpSys Chose to Support Its Clients with ClickUp

This section might be more subjective than the rest of the article. At UpSys, we've leveraged our years of experience with project management tools to serve our clients. Feedback from our clients combined with our tests on various project management applications led us to build expertise in ClickUp. Indeed, ClickUp's hierarchical structure, coupled with the richness of its features and the responsiveness of its support and development team, allows us to confidently recommend this solution. If you want to learn more about ClickUp and UpSys's support, schedule a free appointment here.

These final choices between Asana and ClickUp largely depend on your team's needs, budget, and capacity to learn new tools. Whichever solution you choose, it should enable you and your team to manage projects effectively, collaborate seamlessly, and ultimately, increase productivity and success.